Saint George St George Greek Orthodox Church - Piscataway, New Jersey
Home About Us Organizations EducationCalendar

 



Messages from George Petrantonakis, President of St. George Board of Trustees on the UPR issue

May 4th, 2006

Dear Member of our Community:

Christos Anesti!

As many of you have heard, the Metropolis of New Jersey is demanding that our community adopt and implement the Uniform Parish Regulations (UPR) of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America. They are requesting adoption be completed by August 31, 2006.

Presently we are governed by our own Constitution, a document that has been in place since 1924. Adoption of the UPR would effectively replace our Constitution and require our community to operate within the specific rules and regulations of the UPR and related regulations of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America.

There are many questions about the UPR and about the effects its adoption will have on our community and its operations. This is a critical matter for the entire community to decide and this letter is to advise you of the steps that will be taken to inform and educate you on the UPR.

1) First, we must all become familiar with the UPR. To do so, you can either access the document on the Archdiocese web site, www.GOARCH.ORG or click here or visit St. George Church office during working hours to pick up a hard copy. A copy of the UPR will also be available in the Narthex in Greek and in English.

2) Second, a General Assembly meeting will be held on Sunday, June 11th. At that time, a presentation on the UPR will be made. We anticipate a representative of the Metropolis of New Jersey will attend to discuss the UPR and answer your questions.

3) Third, in mid-May, you will receive a letter outlining specific points of the UPR and of our current Constitution as well as the voting procedures. Note that voting will be held in June! This letter will also detail what will happen if the UPR is not adopted.

The future of the St. George Greek Orthodox community is a concern for all of us. Should the UPR be adopted, there will be a great impact on our community, and therefore it is a document that everyone must read and understand. Should it not be adopted, the impact will be great as well.

Your Board of Trustees welcomes the opportunity to speak with you and to respond to your questions and concerns. We will keep you informed as this important process moves forward.

Sincerely,

George Petrantonakis
President St George Board of Trustees

 


May 22nd, 2006

Dear Member of our Community:

Christos Anesti!

As you have recently been informed in the letter of May 4, 2006, the Metropolis of New Jersey is demanding that our Community adopt and implement the Uniform Parish Regulations (UPR) of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America by August 31, 2006. The Board of Trustees and the UPR Committee have been working diligently to sort through the UPR and this letter is to advise you of our progress.

1. This is to remind you that a special General Assembly meeting will be held on Sunday, June 11, 2006. We have been advised that the Chancellor of the Metropolis, Reverend Stavropoulos, and the Metropolis' attorney will attend to discuss the UPR and answer your questions.

2. Having further considered the matter of the UPR, the Board of Trustees and the UPR Committee have decided to seek an outside, independent legal opinion on several of the issues. Concurrently, we will continue with the voting procedure and will call for the question at our General Assembly meeting of June 11, 2006. If we have sufficient representation of our Community, that being 2/3rds of the voting membership (478 regular members as of December 31, 2005), a vote will be taken.

3. To assist you in understanding the differences between our Constitution and the UPR, the enclosed pages (see immediately below) represent a summary comparison of the major points of the UPR which are of concern to the UPR Committee and the Board of Trustees. As you read this, we again urge you to acquaint yourself with the UPR by accessing the document on the Archdiocese web site, www.GOARCH.ORG or visiting our St. George Church office during working hours to pick up a hard copy. Copies of the UPR and of our Constitution are also now available in the Narthex in Greek and in English.

This is a very complex subject which will take a great deal of time. Consequently the General Assembly meeting will be limited only to the UPR question.

Our Community has been tested with many difficulties and has overcome each and every one throughout our existence. The Board of Trustees and the UPR Committee remain committed to providing you with as much information as possible on our Constitution (our present governing document) and the UPR. However we cannot work through this process alone. We ask that all members of the Community provide your support. We need everyone to engage in an effective and fruitful dialog at the General Assembly meeting and with your Board of Trustees. We will continue to keep you informed of our progress.

Sincerely,

George Petrantonakis
President Board of Trustees

Summary Comparison of St. George Constitution versus UPR

 

Issue

 

St. George

Constitution

 

Uniform Parish Regulations

(UPR)

 

UPR

Article

 

1.

Assets

 

 

Buying, selling, mortgaging of properties

Managed by Board of Trustees

 

 

If the Community is dissolved, all properties and assets are also dissolved and the fiscal dividends divided amongst the parishioners.

 

Managed by Board of Trustees and  requires approval of membership by vote

 

The Parish holds title to its real estate and personal property in its corporate name.  Parish Council, in consultation with Priest, administer property for the benefit of the Parish.

 

All purchasing and selling of properties and/or assets requires 2/3rds approval of the membership and then approval of Metropolitan.

 

All assets, including real estate may be, under certain circumstances (if Parish is deemed to be in canonical disorder), seized by the Metropolis.

 

16

 

 

 

22

 

 

 

29

2.

Board of Trustees

 

 

 

 

 

 

Election procedures

 

Priest is permitted to attend Board meetings as an observer and Community employee but is not considered a member or entitled to a vote.

 

 

 

 

Trustees are elected alternate years by members at General Assembly

Priest is a non-voting member. However, has the power which permits him to act as an equal to the President and/or can supersede the President. Removal of a Trustee can occur by the Metropolitan at the Priest’s recommendation. Removal of a Trustee cannot be brought up at a General Assembly.

 

Election procedures:

  • Candidates must be approved by Priest prior to being nominated
  • Candidates must attend a seminar and sign statement of understanding and acceptance of the UPR.
  • Elections must be ratified by Metropolitan
  • Priest has authority to recommend removal of Board members and replace those members with those of his choosing.
  • Metropolitan has power to cancel or void elections.
  • Metropolitan has power to appoint a member to the Board who is from another community.

 

24, 15

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25, 26

3.

Personnel Matters

  • Hiring/firing staff

 

 

  • Disciplinary matters

 

 

  • Priest salary

 

Managed by Board of Trustees

 

 

General Assembly can dismiss the Priest

 

 

Determined by Board using guidelines from Archdiocese

 

 

All Community personnel matters including hiring/dismissal must have consent of the Priest.

 

The Metropolitan makes the sole decision to transfer or dismiss a Priest

 

The Board is bound by Archdiocese guidelines

 

29, 17

 

 

 

 

 

17

4.

Priest’s role in Community

 

 

Priest may attend Community organization meetings and provides guidance.

Priest has the power to control and possibly dissolve all Community organizations related to the Archdiocese since their by-laws are also subject to Metropolis and Priest approval. All organizations accept the UPR and other Archdiocese regulations and the lead role of the Priest.

 

19, 15

5.

 

 

 

 

General Financial Decisions

 

 

Made by elected Board of Trustees and, in  certain cases require ratification and approval of General Assembly. Recommendations also made by Treasurer. Financial records are audited and certified annually by CPA.

 

Priest has power to take control over financial affairs, books and records since the Priest must also certify Community financial statements. Final say of financial aspects is under control of the Priest.

 

34

6.

Total Commitment Payment to the Archdiocese

Though not in the Constitution, the amount is set by Archdiocese, approved by Board of Trustees

 

Commitment must be met monthly or:

  • Elections will not be ratified
  • Total commitment amount may be raised
  • An audit of records may occur and cost will be borne by the Community
  • Community’s delegates to Clergy-Laity Cong.  and meetings will not be allowed to vote
  • If Community financial records are not submitted upon request within 30 days, the Archdiocese and Metropolis has right to increase the Total Commitment by 25%

 

34

7.

Modifications to the governing document

 

  1. UPR supersedes Constitution

 

  1. Modifications

If 2/3rds of the regular members demand modifications  in writing.

 

To be adopted Constitution must be modified to accept UPR.

 

 

 

Regulations may be amended as provided in the Archdiocesan Charter and such changes must then be ratified by the Ecumenical Patriarch. Once the amendments are approved, they must be adhered to by all communities.

 

The Community cannot change our Constitution subsequent to UPR adoption and acceptance of all related Archdiocese regulations without approval of the Archdiocese.

35

 

21

 

 

21

 


 

June 4th, 2006 

Dear Member of our Community:

This letter is to advise you of the voting procedures that will be followed at the General Assembly meeting on Sunday, June 11, 2006.

As you have been informed in previous letters from our Board of Trustees, the Metropolis of New Jersey is demanding that our Community adopt and implement the Uniform Parish Regulations (UPR) of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America by August 31, 2006.  If our Community does not adopt the UPR by this deadline, we will be faced with possible severe consequences!!  In order to implement the UPR regulations and replace our present Constitution (our legal governing document), such a decision must pass a General Assembly vote.  Therefore, a special General Assembly meeting to discuss and decide on the UPR has been called for Sunday, June 11, 2006.  The voting procedures that will be followed are in accordance with our Constitution.

The following are the voting procedures:

 

1.

A motion may be entertained to request amending of our Constitution to adopt the UPR.  If there is a second to the motion then a discussion period will follow.  After the discussion period has ended, there will be a call for the question.

 

Note: The question will be called only if the required 2/3rds majority of the membership is present.

 

2.

Ballots will be distributed to members who are in good standing.  Only ballots received from members in good standing will be counted.  The Board of Trustees will verify all names against the membership record.

3.

The ballots will be counted on Sunday, June 11, 2006.  Only ballots received at this General Assembly meeting will be counted.

4.

If your ballot is received without a preference it will be discarded.

5.

The results of the vote will be announced once all ballots have been counted.

6.

All ballots will be kept strictly confidential.

 

All members are required to attend this meeting!  It is our duty and obligation as members to attend this meeting and support our Community and its efforts in this important democratic process.  Remember, this meeting is to decide the future of our community and this may be your only opportunity to express your opinion and to decide, by your vote, on its future.  If you are absent and a non-participant in this process, you pass up what may be your only chance to have a say in the direction and the future of our Greek Orthodox Community of St. George and of our St. George Greek Orthodox Church in Piscataway.  Please take advantage of this opportunity to vote and make your voice count in the final decision!

 

We look forward to an informative and productive meeting on June 11.

Sincerely,

George Petrantonakis
President Board of Trustees

 


July 31, 2006

Dear Member of our Community:

This letter is to update you on issues relating to the Uniform Parish Regulations (UPR), which the Metropolis of New Jersey has requested that we adopt by August 31st , 2006.

Since we learned of this impending deadline, the Board of Trustees, in conjunction with the UPR Committee, has been working to address the issues presented, and to find a satisfactory solution for our beloved Community.  Following our last letter to you in May 2006, a special General Assembly meeting was held on June 11th.  The objectives for this meeting were to: (a) communicate with our Community important issues related to the UPR; (b) allow the members to ask questions to the representatives of the Metropolis who were present, Chancellor Anargyros Stavropoulos and Attorney Costas Economides; and (c) allow the Community to vote on the adoption of the UPR if the required number of members was present. 

We wish to express our gratitude and appreciation to all the members who participated at the meeting.  The meeting allowed for a good exchange of information and perspectives, however, we did not have the required two- thirds of the Community present at the General Assembly meeting, in order for a vote to be held.   As you may recall, the key issue that we are facing is that our Community adopted a legal constitution in 1924, which currently serves as our governing document.  This constitution prevents us from being in complete compliance with the UPR of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America.  In order to adopt the UPR, two-thirds of our paid members must vote to revise our constitution. 

Following the General Assembly meeting, these actions were taken by the Board of Trustees:

 

1.       A letter was submitted to His Eminence Metropolitan Evangelos on June 19th, 2006, indicating that the Community would abide by the UPR regulations to the extent that such requirements did not conflict with our Community’s Constitution (attached).

 

2.       A letter was submitted to His Eminence Archbishop Demetrios of America, on July 8th, 2006, explaining the difficult situation our Community is in and asking for his intervention (attached).


A meeting was held on July 11th between the Metropolitan, Father Alex, Mr. Antonis Kalogridis, acting Board President, and Maria Kaouris Christodoulatos, Treasurer.   On behalf of the Metropolis, in addition to His Eminence Metropolitan Evangelos, the meeting was attended by Chancellor Anargyros Stavropoulos and the Metropolis’ attorney, Mr. Economides. 


The discussion with the Metropolitan was constructive   His Eminence was clear about his expectations and provided the following input:

 

1.       His position about our Community conforming to the requirements of the UPR remains completely unchanged.

2.       He sees it as his ecclesiastical duty to ensure that this Community, as all the other communities, conforms to the requirements of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America.  

3.       He believes that he has provided us with sufficient opportunity to adopt the UPR.

4.       The Metropolitan is well aware that ours is a large and vibrant Community, and he is not trying to harm or alienate it. 

5.       The Metropolitan explained that he is not looking for a letter from our Community indicating that we accept the terms of the UPR; he is rather seeking that we hold our elections in December in accordance with the provisions of the UPR.

 

The Board Members discussed the difficulties our Community is facing on this issue, and the impossible task of taking any meaningful actions by the stated deadline of August 31st.  They discussed the efforts and actions to date, the difficulty of obtaining a two-thirds vote, and the challenge of accomplishing anything at this time of the year, when the majority of the Community is away. 

The Metropolitan was understanding despite his stated positions above, and agreed to extend the deadline for us to December 1st, 2006.  This is a very positive development and the Board feels that it will enable further communication with the members of our Community and improved ability for all of us to understand the issues at hand.  This should put our Community in a better position to make the most prudent decisions for its future and well being.    

As part of the effort to achieve the above goals, the Board intends to call another special General Assembly meeting in September.  Our Community will receive correspondence pertaining to this in the latter part of August.  Following the General Assembly meeting, we expect that a proxy ballot will be sent to each member by mail to vote on the UPR adoption.  This should be taking place in October.

In closing, we wish to reiterate that your Board of Trustees is committed to resolving the issues we are currently facing, and continuing a productive and harmonious relationship with the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, with which we have worked  cooperatively as a founding Community since 1922.  The Board of Trustees will continue to serve you faithfully and inform you of developments as we proceed.

Sincerely,

On behalf of the Board,

Antonis Kalogridis
Acting President of the Board of Trustees